There is no need to write an introduction in terms of why we’ve pulled together this piece. What we at Green Square have done is gather our thoughts and learnings, putting them together with the experience of various peers in the industry who have been through dark times before. We hope that what follows may be a useful guide to help agencies through a period of extreme uncertainty and I would like to give specific thanks to our friends Noel Penrose and Chris Savage who have added valuable insight.
There are three key areas that need to be considered – leadership, clients and commercial. Let’s start with the former.
Particularly in the current maelstrom, leadership is about giving people confidence and faith when what they are probably experiencing is fear; fear for their health, their job and their livelihoods. However, what leaders must not do is bullsh*t or stick their heads in the sand. They will not have all the answers, the situation is fluid, things change daily and may well get worse before they get better. People need to be told this and reassured that their leader will do the best they can in these constantly changing circumstances.
People need to see calm leaders who encourage, support and give optimism wherever possible, whilst keeping to the truth. It’s completely expected for a leader to tell people they don’t have all the answers and that their teams will constantly need to pivot depending on how the situation evolves and react to whatever legislation and government support is made available.
And, as leaders, bear in mind you are not alone. Many people are in exactly the same position as you – experiencing the same fears, the same self-doubt, wanting to know if they are doing the right thing. Reach out to your peers and, if you don’t have anyone you feel you can easily chat with, consider using a coach. Non-execs are also excellent sounding boards at times like these, indeed this is when they should come into their own.
- Communicate regularly with your staff and particularly with your direct reports. Do video calls for all staff if you are able to, its personal and as intimate as we can get right now. If you can’t, then send some other form of company-wide communications. People will crave information and communication, even if there’s no new news, so make sure they get it.
- Ensure that everyone in the senior management team has bought into the plan and is mirroring what is being said. People need reassurance, they do not want mixed messages. The COO, CFO, HR Director etc must all bang the same drum – these are the senior players that people turn to for further reassurance.
- People need to know what you expect from them, the key issues the business is facing and what you can collectively do to mitigate the risks. Nothing unites like a common enemy – the enemy in this case being a virus. None of us could have anticipated such an event collapsing a global economy so swiftly.
- Prepare a schedule for how staff should operate when working from home, get it down on paper, create the framework for people. Some staff may have to manage children that are now unexpectedly at home, or ill relatives. Understand what can be done to mitigate the impact of these things and where you can be flexible.
- Alongside giving direction, don’t forget to be humane. People need empathy, particularly in tough times. There may be some very tough decisions regarding your staff base despite government intervention and support. When these decisions are made, be decisive and try to do it once. “Death by a thousand cuts” breeds fear and mistrust.
- Do not procrastinate. This situation is likely to get worse before it gets better. Don’t rely on false assumptions that the next roll of the dice will come up a six. Implement the plan and stick to it, whilst allowing pivot points when things don’t pan out as expected.
- Scenario plan in the event of your own illness and those of the management team. Who will take over from whom? In theory those affected will recover within 7 days from symptoms starting, but many could fall more seriously ill and families will need to remain self-isolated for longer. Make sure you have the succession plan (albeit hopefully temporary) in place now.
One of the biggest risks is client spend being reduced or pulled. For some businesses the likelihood of this happening will be high. For others, involved in things such as streaming, online content, delivery services etc – the risks will likely be much lower. A clear balance needs to be made between ensuring clients contracted to work with you continue to abide by their obligations, whilst not burning a long term, respected client relationship for short-term cash inflow.
- This is the time to really focus on existing client relationships. As this is not a typical recession situation, and virtually everybody will be impacted and in survival mode, it’s not one where you can easily ask friendly clients for support. What you should be doing is regularly checking in with your clients, making sure they are well and offering any support you can realistically give. Focus on your clients, not yourselves, it needs to be all about them – understand the crises they are facing and how you can possibly help mitigate their problems. This is the time to focus on nurturing the client relationships you have and to revisit lapsed clients too. Strengthen those relationships.
- Get key client plans in place and review at least weekly. Have specific responsibilities by individual and focus on ensuring agreed actions are taken. Ensure your best people are all client facing and client engaged. This applies to those lapsed clients also. Go back through your invoices, who have you worked for in the last 3 years that you no longer have live projects with? Follow them up, check that they are OK.
- Clients for which you have committed projects must be prioritised and those that have promised work to you promptly followed up to get that work locked down. The world hasn’t stopped. People are still working, albeit mostly remotely, and you need to focus on those clients where the work will come from.
- Continually review your pipeline and be pragmatic and realistic, not optimistic. Understand what’s gone, going ‘on hold’, what’s still a live prospect and what needs to be done to convert it.
- Understand your clients’ external focusses and drivers and what you can provide to facilitate them in delivering their objectives. There’s no point offering them your regular services if their key priorities have changed and you are no longer relevant. Focus only on services that are relevant for today. Be proactive in suggesting you adapt or delay work already underway, where it no longer makes sense to continue that project.
- Look for work, not budgets. This may not be services you currently provide for a client, but services you provide for others that your other clients may need. Focus on challenges you can solve for them and how you will go about delivering the solutions. In a recession scenario, long-term brand building quickly gets sidelined for short-term sales initiatives. Think about how you can support your clients in helping them shift product short-term and protect their own revenue streams.
- Focus on low-hanging fruit. What work can you quickly pick up, deliver and get paid for? To the extent you have not already done so, productise your offering where possible “This is what we do, this is how we do it, this is who we do it for and this is how much it costs”. Make your services easy to understand and easy to buy.
- Stay close to your referral partners. If you use a lead generation firm or have a referral program in place, ensure you fully maximise opportunities through these channels. But be careful to properly evaluate new work coming in – watch out for those looking for a cheap deal or timewasters searching for free ideas and advice. Be politely upfront with new prospects, you need to establish that work actually exists and, more importantly, that you will be paid.
- Crank up your PR – this is an incredibly important time to drive awareness and profile. Develop relevant articles and thought leadership pieces that will be valuable to clients and potential clients. Get them out by email, into the trade press and on social media.
- Avoid discounting. Just because we are in this situation it does not mean you should cut your pricing. If you do this then it is very hard to raise them again once we are out the other side. An alternative is to break projects into stages, with payments linked to delivery of each stage. This way clients will not have the worry of a large fee commitment (so more likely to progress the work) and you have reduced the risk of non-payment at the end of the project.
- These circumstances should also not be used as an excuse for clients not paying their invoices. You need to ensure everyone with responsibility for chasing in debtors is onto it. Slow payers are likely to turn into bad debts. If you have clients that literally can’t pay, then you will need to look at breaking the debt into bite sized chunks. If it’s a case of them being able to pay but just choosing not to, then given their behaviour, you have to decide if this is a client you really want once we all get through this. If not, go legal early or you will find yourself at the back of the queue.
- Clients may come out of this with different business models and different marketing strategies. Understand what you can do to aid their recovery, how their models may have shifted and how your offer needs to be adapted to assist them going forward. Keep track of ideas you have that may help clients with their recovery phases.
The following are the more hard-nosed financial impact areas that need to be considered. This does not make easy reading and you must take into account your legal obligations as well as the need for humanity and integrity. You must also take proper advice from your relevant professional advisers.
- Be absolutely realistic regarding revenue forecasts and cashflow. Do not kid yourselves it will all get better in the near term. It could get worse.
- Build a worst-case revenue forecast and assume all projects that have not been signed off and committed to will be put on hold, so make sure you strip out anything that is not contracted. Now is not a time for revenue forecasts based on hoping completed pitches out there actually convert. Clients will be cancelling and delaying projects, anticipate retainer fees ceasing. Go through each contracted client and identify where the ‘at risk’ points are for projects being cancelled or postponed.
- Build a cashflow forecast. Based on the most dire revenue forecast above, when will you run out of cash on a business as usual basis? This is your starting point for the actions below that you need to consider.
- Get an immediate grip on your costs. Focus on low hanging fruit. Immediately remove any superfluous and un-necessary costs that can be cut – this is not just cancelling the entertainment streaming subscriptions when no-one is in the office. This will include contractors and freelancers who are not currently involved in client projects that can be stood down, but bear in mind you should try and look after those valued and talented freelancers who will be snapped up by other organisations when normality returns. Freeze hiring and pay rises. All discretionary expenditure must be stopped. Look at every line in the P&L to find savings, work with suppliers where possible to mitigate costs. Focus on where any savings can be made, no matter how small.
- Your biggest cost is likely to be your staff. In the UK, you need to consider making those not currently working on projects ‘furloughed workers’. The UK government has said it will reimburse 80% of furloughed workers salaries up to a cap of £2,500 per employee. This may be a viable alternative to a wholescale redundancy plan. You will need to check eligibility criteria and bear in mind you will still be liable for 20% of the salary cost / amounts above the cap. Or perhaps it is a combination of this and / or seeking government backed lending – the doors to this opened on 23 March.
A direct link to the UK government support initiatives can be found here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/guidance-to-employers-and-businesses-about-covid-19/covid-19-support-for-businesses
- Consider asking people to go part time or temporarily seconding staff into clients. Bear in mind there is always a minimum point you can’t cut below and still be able to deliver the work, but don’t let this be an excuse for not taking hard actions from the outset.
- Owners and directors need to lead from the front and one such step would be a salary deferral or temporary pay cut (whilst continuing to work full time). If this is what the leadership decides to do, make it clear to the staff you are doing this. It is important they see you sharing the pain.
- Evaluate your property situation – can you temporarily sublet, share with others or negotiate a rental deferral?
- Once you have done the above, most importantly, develop a forecast with key metrics and plan future ‘trigger points’. These trigger points will be actions you will take should your key metrics not be met. For example, if actual revenue is 5% below the forecast in a given month you will make further staff reductions or request everyone goes part time.
- It’s not all about cost-cutting. Look at efficiencies – are there ways you could be doing things differently, better or faster? In the good times these things get overlooked, in the bad times they become a necessary point of focus.
- Be ruthless in chasing in unpaid invoices and watch out for potential bad debts. Clients may wish to delay paying you – see previous notes on this – but job losses and restructuring announcements at client companies are a sure sign that you may not be paid on time.
- Get everyone focused on profit. Do not sell work at a discount simply to get money in. You will be held to delivering that work in the future, even if you have sold it unprofitably. Understand the ramifications of any offers you are making to your clients and whether they are sustainable.
- Is there an opportunity to come together with other agencies to best effect an increasing breadth of offering? In the case of needing to rationalise staff, is there an opportunity to ‘huddle together to keep warm’ or temporarily outsource the work you otherwise would have done together with some staff? Even perhaps to a friendly competitor?
- Where you are part of a group of companies, have private equity backing or external shareholders, you will be under more intense pressure to provide constant financial updates. Understand exactly what your investors need and manage that relationship carefully. Investors do not like nasty unexpected shocks, keep them updated on your plan, how it is progressing and when you need to make changes to that plan.
And what when this is all over?
In the words of Benjamin Franklin “Out of adversity comes opportunity”.
In many cases the business models will change, not simply because of need, but because we will have had to do things differently – less travel and mobility, more reliance on the internet for online meetings and people will have focused on things they can do at home which may be different to their day to day routines. This may drive different consumer behaviour as people will have had new experiences – from simpler things such as an obvious growth in home learning and home cooking, through to a potential accelerated decline of the high street as the vast majority of people will have been forced to do everything online.
These events force the hand of innovation as it becomes a necessity to find new ways of doing things. You will need to ensure your business can adapt to whatever new paradigms may exist.
As long as you behaved with compassion and integrity throughout and maintained excellent relationships with your most important business constituents – your clients and your staff – you will hopefully come through this just fine and in a good position to rebuild.
At the end of the day, it is important not to bury our heads in the face of adversity. Despite the bleak current outlook, there will be new opportunities, and these could be very exciting.
In the meantime, please stay safe and hope you all keep healthy.