Merge or Sell Your Agency? When a Merger Beats a Sale

Merge or Sell Your Agency? When a Merger Beats a Sale

When a merger beats a sale, how each side is valued, and what has to be agreed besides the split.

Simon Morgan, Partner at Agency Futures, talking to camera about whether to merge or sell an agency

There is no shortage of advice on what makes a strong agency: a clear specialism, a known brand, healthy margins, loyal clients, a team that doesn't depend on the founder. All of it matters. But when we sit down with an owner to work out what their agency is worth, one thing matters more than any other, and that is scale.

Scale used to mean headcount. The bigger the team, the bigger the agency, and the more a buyer would pay for each dollar of profit. That link is weaker today. With better tools, automation and a wider bench of freelancers, an agency can grow its revenue and profit without hiring at the same rate. What hasn't changed is how hard it is to get there on your own. Winning enough new work, year after year, to move from one valuation band to the next is fiendishly difficult, and most founders spend years trying.

That is why the merger is such an often overlooked strategy. Two agencies that fit together can reach in one step the scale each would take years to build alone, and scale is what buyers pay for. It isn't right for everyone, and the rest of this guide is about how to tell.

The short answer. Sell if you want cash and a clear exit in the next two or three years. Merge if you want to keep building, your agency is below the size buyers pay most for, and you can find a partner whose clients or skills complete yours. Two agencies combined can move into a higher valuation band, so a merger is often the step before a better sale rather than an alternative to one. The price is shared control, no cash today, and the hard work of making two teams one.

Selling and merging are different deals

In a sale, a buyer pays you for your shares, usually some in cash at completion and the rest later, often through an earn-out. You hand over control and, after a transition period, you leave.

In a merger, two agencies combine and their owners hold shares in the bigger business, in proportion to what each brings. Usually nobody is paid cash at the start. You keep working, you share the decisions, and you own a smaller slice of something larger. Many founders then sell the combined agency a few years later.

When selling is the better route

  • You want to step back within two or three years, or you need the cash now.

  • A buyer will pay for something only you have, such as a specialism or a client base it wants.

  • Your agency is already large enough to sit in a strong valuation band on its own.

  • You don't want a partner. Running a business with another founder is a real change, and not everyone wants it.

When merging is the better route

  • You want to keep building, and selling now would leave value on the table.

  • Your agency is below the size buyers pay most for, and growing alone would take years.

  • Another agency fills a gap you can't fill quickly: a capability, a sector, a geography, or the next generation of leaders.

  • You're carrying the business largely on your own and want a partner in the decisions.

Why size changes the price

Buyers pay a multiple of normalised EBITDA, and the multiple rises with size. Our published bands run from 3.0x to 4.5x for agencies earning under 500k, to 5.0x to 7.0x between 1.5m and 5m. That is why combining two agencies can be worth more than the two apart.

Take two agencies each earning 1.0m of normalised EBITDA. On our published valuation curve, each is worth about 4.75x, or 4.75m, so 9.5m between them. Combined, they earn 2.0m, which reads about 5.49x on the same curve: roughly 10.97m, or about 15% more for the same earnings.

Two cautions. The uplift is only realised when the combined agency is sold, and buyers want to see two or three years of combined accounts first, so it rewards founders who will stay for that period. And it assumes the two businesses actually work as one: a merger that keeps two cultures and two cost bases side by side gets valued as two agencies, not one.

That 15% comes from size alone, on the same earnings, so it is the floor rather than the goal. In the best mergers the two teams come together well and use their combined scale to take out cost: one finance function, one set of systems, shared premises and overheads, so more of every dollar of revenue reaches profit. They then build a proposition neither agency could offer alone, which wins larger clients and gets the organic growth flywheel spinning, the growth that was so hard to find at half the size. From there the founders have a choice. They can go to market as a bigger, more profitable agency with a growth story, which is a far more attractive prospect for larger buyers. Or they can enjoy a more profitable business for longer and take a different exit path later, such as a management buyout or a gradual handover to the next generation of leaders.

How each side is valued

A merger asks two questions that are easy to confuse: what the combined agency is worth, which both sides want to be as high as possible, and how it divides between them, which is the only part where one side's gain is the other's loss. Keep them apart. Anything the two businesses have in common changes what the group is worth but should not move the split.

Write the rules down before anyone shares a figure. Agree how earnings will be measured and how the split will be calculated first, so no number anchors the conversation. Then put both businesses on the same basis. Owners who pay themselves by salary on one side and by dividend on the other, or two different ways of recognising revenue, can move the split by around ten points before anything else is discussed. Price each owner's role at a market salary, and apply one revenue and cost policy to both.

The split then follows what each side contributes:

  • Earnings first, on one multiple. Each side's normalised EBITDA, with a single multiple taken from the combined agency's band. One multiple divides out of the ratio, so the split follows earnings and a band boundary can't hand one side a windfall.

  • Then quality, within a limit. Growth, client concentration, recurring revenue and how much each business depends on its owners can move the split either way, by an amount capped in advance.

  • Then the balance sheet. Cash, debt and working capital are settled before completion, or evened out with a cash payment, so neither side brings more or less than the split assumes.

The point is a split that both sides, and their accountants, can reproduce from the same published rules. When each owner can check the arithmetic, the negotiation moves on to the things that decide whether a merger works.

What has to be agreed besides the split

  • Who leads. Roles, titles and who has the final say on what.

  • The board. Its make-up, what it decides, and how deadlock is broken. A common shape is an equal number of seats for each founding group, a short list of decisions that need both groups' consent, a step-by-step route out of deadlock, and an independent chair before the business goes to market.

  • Pay. Agree the principle early: no founder is worse off because of the merger. How owners are paid for their roles is settled separately from what their shares earn, and in private.

  • The way out. What happens if one founder wants to leave, and how the combined business is sold later.

  • Integration. One finance system, how the teams and clients come together, and by when. On the brand, many merged agencies keep both names under a group name at first and decide on a single brand within one to three years.

One adviser and one set of documents

In a sale, each side hires its own adviser and its own lawyer, and a good part of the legal bill and the timetable goes on two firms marking up each other's drafts. A merger doesn't have to work that way, because both owners want the same outcome: a combined business that works. When we run a merger we act for both sides and advocate for neither, and the same terms apply to each. One lawyer then drafts a single set of documents from the terms both founders have agreed, with warranties that apply equally to both sides.

Each founder still has those documents reviewed by their own lawyer and takes their own tax advice, and that part isn't optional. But reviewing an agreed draft is a smaller job than writing a rival one, and there are no rounds of competing mark-ups to pay for or wait on.

Work together before you commit

Two agencies can look right on paper and still not work as one. The only reliable test is to do real work together before signing anything, and to give it a few months. Ways to do it, roughly from lightest to deepest:

  • Pitch together. A joint pitch for a new client shows how the two teams think, price and share credit under pressure, and whether a client buys the combined offer.

  • Deliver a project together. One agency brings the other in on a live client. It tests delivery standards, hand-offs and how each side treats the other's client.

  • Refer work to each other. A simple referral arrangement with a revenue share tests trust and how each side handles money, at low stakes.

  • Swap a senior person. A few weeks inside the other agency tells you more about its culture than any meeting.

  • Write the combined plan together. Draft the first-year plan for the merged business as a working session. If the founders can't agree a plan now, they won't agree on running the business later.

  • Run a shadow month. Hold a few joint pipeline, people and finance reviews as if already merged, so problems surface while walking away is still easy.

  • Meet each other's people. Spend time with the other side's key clients and team leads, not just its founders.

Agree up front what would end it, and keep the trial framed as a partnership so clients and staff aren't unsettled. Share financial information only under a non-disclosure agreement.

How a merger runs

  1. Find and test the fit. Strategic, cultural and financial, tested by working together on a pitch or a project. Most possible matches fail here, and that is the cheapest place for them to fail.

  2. Value both sides and agree the split. On the same basis, in the open.

  3. Agree the terms. Leadership, board, pay and the way out, set out in heads of terms.

  4. Due diligence, both ways. Each side checks the other's numbers, contracts and people.

  5. Legal documents and completion. Usually a new holding company that both sets of owners hold shares in, or one agency acquiring the other for shares.

  6. Integration. The part that decides whether the merger was worth doing.

Decide in a set order: the split first, then leadership and the team, then structure and governance, with the brand and the detail of integration after heads of terms. Close each decision before opening the next, and don't reopen it.

Expect about three months from a match to a signed letter of intent, and six to twelve months to completion. Most of the time goes on decisions and information, not documents. The structure affects tax, so take advice before heads of terms.

Merge now, sell later

For many founders the real choice isn't merge or sell, it's when. Merging first can lift a smaller agency into a better valuation band and give a buyer a more complete business, with a leadership team that doesn't depend on any one founder. Selling later then happens from a stronger position.

How Agency Futures helps

We advise on both routes, and on the choice between them, for agencies in Australia, the UK, Europe and North America. For mergers we find and test partners, value both sides on our published method, structure the terms and plan the integration. For smaller agencies, Merge Express is our structured programme for finding a culturally aligned partner. If you're weighing up the two, start a conversation.

For advice on merging with another agency, contact us here.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to merge or sell an agency?

Sell if you want cash and an exit within two or three years. Merge if you want to keep building and your agency is below the size buyers pay most for, since a combined agency can sell later at a higher multiple.

How do you split ownership in an agency merger?

Agree the rules before anyone shares a figure, put both agencies on the same basis (owners' roles priced at market, one revenue policy), then split on normalised EBITDA using one multiple for both. Growth, concentration, recurring revenue and owner dependence adjust it within a cap, and cash, debt and working capital are evened out so the split holds.

Do you get paid when your agency merges?

Usually not at the start. Owners receive shares in the combined business rather than cash, and realise the value when it is later sold.

How do you know if two agencies will work well together?

Work together before committing. A joint pitch, a shared client project or a few months of joint planning shows how the teams collaborate, share credit and handle disagreement, far better than meetings between the founders.

Can a merger increase an agency's value?

Yes, if the combined business works as one. Larger agencies earn higher multiples: on our published curve, two agencies earning 1.0m each are worth about 9.5m apart and about 11m combined.

EL PLAYBOOK

The Match-Fit Playbook

M&A de agencias, del crecimiento a la salida. La guía práctica para construir valor en su agencia y afrontar una venta en sus términos, extraída de las operaciones que asesoramos.

¿Pensando en su próximo movimiento?

Hablémoslo con claridad y sin ninguna presión.

Empezar

¿Pensando en su próximo movimiento?

Hablémoslo con claridad y sin ninguna presión.

Empezar

¿Pensando en su próximo movimiento?

Hablémoslo con claridad y sin ninguna presión.

Empezar